Won't Get Fooled Again Borderlands 2 Mission and Achievement Guide

The vast world of Pandora is full of unique side quests, but few require as much deductive reasoning as the Won't Get Fooled Again optional mission in Borderlands 2. Found in the hub city of Sanctuary, this objective shifts the focus away from traditional fast-paced shooting mechanics toward a classic murder mystery setup. Vault Hunters must analyze testimonies from various colorful suspects to find the true culprit behind a sudden crime.
How to Unlock and Initiate the Case
To begin this investigative assignment, players must progress through the main storyline until Sanctuary is officially unlocked as a safe zone. You can find the quest starter by speaking with Marshall Friedman, who is stationed near the town center attempting to solve a shooting. Accepting the task immediately markers four local brothers as the primary suspects in the investigation.
Before guessing randomly, players should carefully interact with each brother to listen to their individual alibis and statements. Paying attention to conflicting details in their timelines will quickly reveal who is hiding the truth from the law. This mission serves as an excellent change of pace from the standard combat loops found throughout the rest of the game.
Analyzing Suspect Testimonies
Each of the four Guster brothers provides a distinct story regarding their location and actions at the time the weapon went off. One brother will claim an absolute alibi, while another might accidentally implicate a family member through a slip of the tongue. Cross-referencing these dialogue lines is essential for narrowing down the pool of suspects without failing the bonus objectives.
The critical clue lies in analyzing the shield mechanics mentioned during the interrogation sequences. The true culprit is Barfly, who forgot to account for how specific shield variations would react during a surprise confrontation. Accusing him correctly on your first attempt completes the investigation phase smoothly.
Unlocking Mission Achievements and Rewards
Successfully completing this side quest counts directly toward global completion milestones across Pandora. It is a mandatory requirement for unlocking the comprehensive achievement tied to clearing all side content in the base game. Taking the time to finish these localized narratives ensures your achievement tracker remains on the right path for a perfect completion run.
In addition to achievement progress, Marshall Friedman rewards the player with a decent chunk of experience points and local currency. The true value, however, comes from experiencing the witty writing and classic humor that defines the classic gearbox formula. Successfully closing the file allows you to move on to tougher challenges waiting out in the dangerous wastes.